(By My Standards / Photo by Holly M. Smith)
From the KY HBPA Media Team / Jennie Rees:
By My Standards and Tom’s d’Etat, two of the top older horses in training, are returning to Louisville via their New Orleans winter base and an Arkansas stopover. Everything has clicked into place for Saturday’s Oaklawn Handicap winner By My Standards. On the other hand, Grade 1 winner Tom’s d’Etat is a horse all dressed up and no place to run.
“They have as much upside as any older horse in the country,” said Bret Calhoun, trainer of By My Standards. “The fact that the Breeders’ Cup is in our backyard this year at Keeneland helps, too.”
Here’s an update on both horses and how they’re being impacted by the coronavirus global pandemic:
By My Standards now No. 3 in poll off Oaklawn win
Social distancing could only last so long when Chester Thomas’ By My Standards won Saturday’s $600,000 Oaklawn Handicap by 1 3/4 lengths over Warrior’s Charge. Thomas, the Madisonville, Ky., entrepreneur who races in the named of Allied Racing, and wife Jennifer had one of their sons and daughter in law and another couple over to their home to watch the race.
“Unfortunately, with the coronavirus we couldn’t be there” at Oaklawn Park in Hot Springs, Ark., Thomas said. “The six of us stayed socially-distanced the best we could until the horse won. Then it was high fives and hugs.”
By My Standards, trained by Bret Calhoun, is 3 for 3 this year after his nine-month layoff following an 11th-place finish in the 2019 Kentucky Derby. His 1 3/4-length victory under Gabriel Saez in the Grade 2 Oaklawn Handicap moved the 4-year-old from eighth to third in this week’s NTRA top thoroughbred poll, including three first-place votes.
“Couldn’t be happier, couldn’t be prouder. Couldn’t be more relieved,” Thomas said. “A lot of horses exit the Kentucky Derby and never win another race in their career. By My Standards had a quarter crack (common hoof problem), was all banged-up from being in the race. Give Bret Calhoun credit. He knew the horse was just a tick off. We did a full body scan on him, identified a couple of things that lit up, nothing major, and determined he just needed some good time off. We think our horse deserves and fits very well in the top echelon of racehorses. He’s starting to show he’s what we thought he’d be last year. We gave him plenty of time and gave him an opportunity to be all that he can be.”
Calhoun said he had a lot of confidence going into the deep and quality field, but that By My Standards’ No. 12 post in the Oaklawn Handicap was a concern.
“He’d never shipped to run and had never been over that surface,” Calhoun said. “Only thing I discussed with Gabe was that I thought the break was going to be the crucial factor. I said, ‘I think if we get away from the gate sharp, we’ve got a chance.’ Lo and behold, he did a great job getting away extremely sharp and, even better, got into a great position on the first turn – honestly a lot better position that I thought we could be in.
“Then I was all worried because he was second off pretty significant fractions. You’re worried maybe it’s going to take too much out of him because he’s not (normally showing) that much early speed. But you could tell early on that he’d gotten pretty comfortable. I felt he would finish strong, which he did.”
The Kentucky Derby remains By My Standards’ only defeat since winning a Fair Grounds maiden race on his fourth attempt, which was followed by victory in last year’s $1 million Louisiana Derby (G2) at 22-1 odds to give Thomas his first graded-stakes win. The son of the Spendthrift Farm stallion Goldencents resumed racing this year with a six-length allowance victory at the Fair Grounds, followed by a three-length score in the $400,000 New Orleans Classic (G2).
“I really thought we were a live horse going into the Kentucky Derby,” Calhoun said. “We were battling a foot, but I think the biggest factor in the Kentucky Derby was the track getting very muddy. He broke a little tardy, lost his position on a speed-biased track with an extreme amount of kickback. It was pretty much race over at the break.
“But going into that race, I thought he was this kind of horse. We gave him all the time off he needed and pointed toward his 4-year-old season — which we always thought would be a better year for him, based on Goldencents winning the Breeders’ Cup Mile two years in a row and seemed to get better with age. This horse was a good-sized horse, but still a bit immature (physically). This year he’s filled out, a lot stronger horse, a lot more muscle. I think that’s why he’s sharper from the gate.”
Thomas, a two-time leading owner at Ellis Park, praises Oaklawn Park and track owner Louis Cella for continuing high-caliber racing without spectators after the sport shut down in most of the country amid the coronavirus pandemic, including Kentucky. Oaklawn split the Arkansas Derby into two divisions that ultimately ran with nine horses each, with the Oaklawn Handicap attracting a full field of 14 entrants (with one scratched).
“In my opinion, the Cellas deserve an Eclipse Award, the way they’ve supported thoroughbred horse racing,” Thomas said of the sport’s highest honor. “Hats off to the Cellas. Unbelievable what they pulled off. They carried the water.”
By My Standards will ship to Churchill Downs next week. Though it’s tempting to pursue a Grade 1 victory in By My Standards’ next start, Thomas and Calhoun said staying home for Churchill’s Grade 2, $500,000 Stephen Foster on June 27 makes sense distance and time-wise.
“We’d like to try to win a Grade I race and that race was downgraded to a Grade 2 last year,” Calhoun said. “But I think it makes sense to stay home, run out of his own stall. I’m in a great spot right now. The horse is fresh, in great form, the timing with the races in the near future look like they’re going to work out for us. Then having the Breeders’ Cup in Kentucky in our own backyard, all that’s very positive for us.”
Thomas also campaigns the 4-year-old Mr. Money, winner of four graded stakes last year and who started his 2-year-old career racing at Ellis Park. Mr. Money, who could run in Churchill Downs’ new $100,000 Blame Stakes May 23 at a one-turn mile, finished sixth over a wet track in the Oaklawn Mile in his first 2020 start. “We just don’t think he liked that track at all,” Thomas said.
His current 3-year-olds include Mr. Big News, winner of the 1 1/8-mile Oaklawn Stakes at 46-1 odds on April 11. “We really believe he’s a legitimate Derby horse,” Thomas said. “He’s especially going to love the distance.”
Allied Racing ranks No. 7 among North American owners for 2020 purse earnings at just under $1 million, while Calhoun ranks No. 9 among trainers at more than $1.9 million.
“We’re still riding the wave,” Thomas said. “It’s been a fun ride, but we know it won’t last forever. Jennifer and I are having the time of our lives. The only thing better would be if we could be at the track.”
Tom’s d’Etat: All dressed up and no place to race
The frustration earlier in the career of Grade 1 Clark Handicap winner Tom’s d’Etat was that G M B Racing’s talented horse missed so much racing while sidelined with niggling physical issues. “He’s had a lot of stay at home social distancing in his life,” trainer Al Stall Jr. wryly observed.
Now 7, Tom’s d’Etat has enjoyed most of two unimpeded years to great success, but the frustration has returned: This time over having a horse ready to run and, amid the coronavirus’ disruption of horse racing, no logical place to race.
Stall’s plan called for Tom’s d’Etat to return off a scheduled freshening in the April 11 Ben Ali at Keeneland. That’s the track where the 2020 Breeders’ Cup will be held and where Tom’s d’Etat won with authority in last fall’s Fayette Stakes before taking Churchill Downs’ Clark Handicap.
However, on March 16, Keeneland canceled its spring meet. Rerouting to the New Orleans Classic at the Fair Grounds, where Tom’s d’Etat was training, was not an option as that field had been set two days earlier. Plan B was going to Arkansas’ Oaklawn Mile, also on April 11, a race Tom’s d’Etat won over the talented Improbable.
Stall opted not to run Tom’s d’Etat back in this past Saturday’s Oaklawn Handicap because he had his eye on the Blame Stakes at 1 1/8 miles on May 30, a new stakes Churchill Downs created as prep for the Stephen Foster.
The day after the Oaklawn Handicap, Churchill Downs’ revised stakes schedule for the track’s shortened spring meet came out with the Blame changed to a mile around one turn. A distance horse, Tom’s d’Etat has only raced around one turn once, and that was because an allowance race came off the turf. Now Tom’s d’Etat instead could be headed to the $300,000 Gold Cup at Santa Anita, a Grade 1 race at 1 1/4 miles on June 6.
Usually the lament of horseplayers is that there are so many similar races clustered together that fields get diluted. Now Stall is just trying to find a two-turn stakes that makes sense timing-wise, saying he doesn’t want to go straight into the June 27 Stephen Foster off a 2 1/2-month layoff and only the one start in the seven months since the Clark.
“I don’t think it’s fair to the horse to go in off a short-stretch mile race against a horse like By My Standards, who has had three good, strong two-turn races so far,” Stall said. “I’m not sure what to do. If I’d known this was going to happen, I might have run in the Oaklawn Handicap. But this didn’t come out until I missed entries. Same thing happened in the New Orleans Classic, with Keeneland canceling after those entries closed. The Alysheba (at Churchill Downs on what would have been the May 1 Oaks card) could have been a back-up race and got canceled.
“I can’t believe things have been so weird. It’s just frustration. Things just haven’t gone his way, but it will get caught up sooner or later. We’ll get him back up to Churchill Downs next week, training him regularly and see what happens.”
Tom’s d’Etat moved up a spot to No. 6 in this week’s NTRA top thoroughbred poll, which is topped by 2019 champion older female Midnight Bisou. At age 7, he’s only run 17 times, with 10 victories. That also means there’s not the wear and tear one might expect to start showing on a horse his age. His seven straight triple-digit speed figures suggest Tom’s d’Etat is as fast as any horse in training.
“He’s actually better because he’s had a regular career for the past two years now,” Stall said. “His time off this winter at the Fair Grounds was just a plain old freshening. We really thought he’d run a good race off the bench, which he does anyway.”